- June 14, 2020
- No Comment
- 1207
CONTRADICTIONS IN THE QURAN:
A CLASSICAL APPROACH
The internet is flooded with lots of material purporting to show numerous contradictions in the Quran. In discussing Islam, detractors often resort to pointing out so-called contradictions in the Quran. The ubiquitous usage of this theme in anti-Islamic polemics shows how much currency this theme holds for the detractors. In most instances, if not all, the detractors discuss the selected contradictions of the Quran without reference at all to Muslim scholarship. This section hopes to act as a corrective to this state of affairs.
Shaykh Muhammad Amīn Al-Shinqīṭi wrote an entire monograph dedicated to dealing with so-called contradictions in the Quran. His book Daf’ Īyhām Al-Idhṭirāb ‘An Ayāt Al-Kitāb provides an extensive treatment of the matter; the book runs close to four hundred pages. This section will provide an overview of Al-Shinqīṭi’s discussion of the so-called contradictions in the Quran. This section is divided into three parts: the first part will outline the 5 key features of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of Quranic verses. These features will be compared to the way detractors usually analyse Quranic verses. The second part will provide 10 examples of contradictions that Al-Shinqīṭi resolves. The second part can be seen as a practical application of the first part’s theory. The third and final part will show how Muslims can use Al-Shinqīṭi’s method to deal with contemporary detractors and their charges of Quranic contradictions.
Part 1: Features of Al-Shinqīṭi’s Analysis of the Quran
Al-Shinqīṭi is the famous Mauritanian scholar. He moved to Saudi Arabia where he taught Tafsir in Masjid Nabawi in the Prophet’s city of Medina. He was the teacher for Shaykh Ibn Baz, the Mufti of Saudi Arabia, Shaykh Ibn Uthaymīn, the world renowned Muslim scholar, and Shaykh Bakr Abu Zayd, the famous scholar who oversaw the publication of Ibn Qayyim’s books in critical editions in modern print. Al-Shinqīṭi’s most famous work is Adhwā Al-Bayān, which is a multi-volume Tafsir that focuses on Quranic intertextuality. The Tafsir’s primary methodology is to let the Quran explain itself. Al-Shinqīṭi later moved to Mecca; he died there in the year 1973.
Unlike his Tafsir, Al-Shinqīṭi’s monograph Daf’ Īyhām Al-Idhṭirāb deals specifically with Quranic contradictions. His methodology and analysis of the Quran found in the monograph is more relevant when dealing with detractors than his Tafsir, because his Tafsir deals with a diffuse variety of topics, whereas the monograph is focused solely on Quranic contradictions. Detractors, for instance, are not interested at all in the rhyming scheme in the Quran. They pose their challenge in the arena of contradictions not rhymes.
The first feature of Al-Shinqīṭi’s treatment of the Quran is his thoroughness. Al-Shinqīṭi organises his book based on Surahs and not based on topics. Al-Shinqīṭi goes through each Surah of the Mushaf, one-by-one, and highlights which verses seem contradictory; he then provides solutions that show the verses are not in fact contradictory. This Surah-by-Surah method is vastly different from how detractors organise their discussion of Quranic contradictions. Usually, detractors will group together similar contradictions under topical headings. For instance: ‘contradictions regarding nature’ or ‘contradictions regarding prophets’ etc. The different organisational methods lead to vastly different understandings of the Quran.
The Surah-by-Surah method of Al-Shinqīṭi views the Quran as a holistic whole. The exhaustive, and at times repetitive, analysis Al-Shinqīṭi provides carefully contextualises all the contradictions within the entire Quranic text. The topical method used by detractors engages in artificial segmentation, where the Quranic text is chopped up into bite-sized segments, and then presented in such a way as if they contradict one another. This artificial segmentation can occur subconsciously, like when detractors search the Quran for verses that refer to a specific topic. Such an approach to the Quran is not exhaustive, but selective. Instead of following the flow of the Quranic text, detractors impose their own arbitrary categories onto the Quranic text.
The second feature of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of the Quran is his copious use of Quranic verses. For instance, Al-Shinqīṭi highlights a single verse that seems to contradict the rest of the Quran. He then provides six different verses that mention the same thing as the highlighted single verse. In another place, Al-Shinqīṭi points to a single verse that might be considered contradictory to the Quran. He then cites more than ten Quranic verses that say the exact same thing as the single verse.
This technique of copious citation that Al-Shinqīṭi uses is highly persuasive. The technique shows that the single verse which is claimed to be contradictory to the Quran is actually widespread across the Quran. Many other verses say the same thing as this single so-called contradictory verse. This proves that the single verse is not a minor verse but is a major theme of the Quran. Once readers notice this, the claim of a contradiction becomes more doubtful. It is one thing to say that a single verse was mistakenly written into the Mushaf which contradicts the overall Quranic text. It is another thing to say that a major theme of the Quran contradicts the overall Quranic text. How can this be if the overall Quranic text is comprised of the major theme?
Al-Shinqīṭi’s technique easily shifts the discussion from individual verses to entire themes in the Quran. By doing this, Al-Shinqīṭi is emphasising that Quranic verses cannot be understood individually; rather, they must be understood thematically. By citing copiously from other Quranic verses that also exhibit the same theme, Al-Shinqīṭi demonstrates how the individual verse that may seem contradictory must first be understood in light of the other verses that are thematically similar.
Detractors do not use this technique at all. A careful look at their works and arguments shows that detractors depend on presenting individual verses and portraying them as contradictory to the Quran. Almost all detractors fail to situate these individual verses into the established themes that comprise the overall Quranic text. If detractors did attempt to move their discussion from the level of individual verses to major themes, they will be forced to first explain an individual verse in the light of many other verses in the Quran. Doing so, however, disadvantages the detractors because it will immediately be clear that there is no black-and-white opposition; since, themes can be sufficiently sophisticated enough to interact with each other without any clear-cut contradiction occurring.
The third feature of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of the Quran is his heavy reliance on Arabic poetry. This not surprising since Al-Shinqīṭi was an expert in Arabic poetry himself. He used Arabic poetry to understand the Quranic language, because Arabic poetry expressed some of the most eloquent usages of Arabic words and grammatical rules ever recorded. By seeing how the most refined expressions of the Arabic language worked, Al-Shinqīṭi could understand how the Quranic language partakes in the excellence of eloquence.
The emphasis Al-Shinqīṭi gives to Arabic poetry cannot be understated. In explaining one verse, Al-Shinqīṭi provides close to 20 different poetic couplets; he does not provide a single hadith. It is guaranteed, beyond any doubt, that detractors who talk about the so-called contradictions of the Quran are totally ignorant of Arabic poetry. The majority of them cannot read Arabic at all. The minority who can read Arabic (as is the case with Arab apostates) are still clueless about Arabic poetry. They may know of Al-Mutanabbi, the great poet of Islam. They may have even heard some of his poetry; since, Al-Mutanabbi’s poems have become popular aphorisms in the Arab world. But they cannot, if challenged, provide a detailed linguistic analysis of a randomly selected poem of Al-Mutanabbi. Since this is the case, there is no surprise why Al-Shinqīṭi and the detractors have a starkly opposed understanding of the Quran. Al-Shinqīṭi’s understanding of the Quranic text is grounded in specialist appreciation for Arabic poetry. The detractors understand the Quranic text while being 100% ignorant of Arabic poetry.
The fourth feature of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of the Quran is his continual usage of Uṣūl Al-Fiqh (‘Principles of Fiqh’). Al-Shinqīṭi provides more direct quotations from Marāqi Al-Su’ūd than from any specific Tafsir book. And what is Marāqi Al-Su’ūd? It is a famous primer on Uṣūl Al-Fiqh based on the Maliki Madthab. Al-Shinqīṭi had provided a full commentary of this famous text in another work. The importance of Uṣūl Al-Fiqh in understanding the Quran is made clear by how Al-Shinqīṭi quotes extensively from the famous primer. It is also made clear by how Al-Shinqīṭi repeatedly uses the phrase “as established in I’lm Al-Uṣūl” when dealing with Quranic verses.
There is a significant difference between Fiqh and Uṣūl Al-Fiqh. Fiqh is the legal rulings themselves. Uṣūl Al-Fiqh is the principles by which the legal rulings can be deduced. Thus, Uṣūl Al-Fiqh is focused on how the evidences from the Quran & Sunnah can be used validly in inferences. In contrast, Fiqh is the judgements passed by use of legal rules. That is why Al-Shinqīṭi’s use of Uṣūl Al-Fiqh becomes pivotal. He is using the principles for deriving legal rulings from the Quran in order to understand the Quran in a coherent manner. From Al-Shinqīṭi’s perspective, the coherence in the Quran can be found using the same valid inferences that result in the coherence of Fiqh. It must be made abundantly clear here: Al-Shinqīṭi is not saying that the coherence of Fiqh informs our understanding of the Quran; rather, he is saying the Uṣūl Al-Fiqh, not Fiqh itself, is what clarifies the coherence of the Quranic text. This difference is substantial, because in the minds of most contemporary readers, when Fiqh is invoked, they directly think of haram and halal rulings. But Uṣūl Al-Fiqh is prior to that; it is before the specific rulings. Al-Shinqīṭi is not talking about fatwas when he says “as established in I’lm Al-Uṣūl”.
Of course detractors never discuss the so-called contradictory verses in the Quran by referring to Uṣūl Al-Fiqh. Most of the detractors are oblivious to the fact that Uṣūl Al-Fiqh has priority when trying to interpret a Quranic verse. They would consider it far-fetched that certain principles must be applied onto the Quran before we can rightly interpret it. But what they think is farfetched is actually the standard procedure in Islamic scholarship. The idea of understanding the Quran without using any prior principles at all is an anathema to the entire history of Islam.
The fifth feature of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of the Quran is his emphasis on Quranic intertextuality. Al-Shinqīṭi is a proponent of the principle “the best interpretation of the Quran is by the Quran”. In one place, Al-Shinqīṭi refers to a view that “many scholars” hold. He rejects this view outright, because it does not conform to some Quranic verses. In another place, Al-Shinqīṭi confidently rejects the majority position of the scholars because the Quran has priority over any majority position.
Detractors usually try to force-fit a contradiction in the Quran by saying that so-and-so scholar explained a verse to mean one thing, while another Quranic verse explicitly says the opposite thing. Following Al-Shinqīṭi’s position, it is easy for Muslims to reject any scholarly explanation that does not conform to the Quran itself. Moreover, detractors seem not to be aware of the critical understanding needed to deal with the Quran. Throughout his monograph, Al-Shinqīṭi favours Ibn Kathir’s views on Tafsir. This does not stop Al-Shinqīṭi from rejecting Ibn Kathir’s view on a certain issue, and criticising Ibn Kathir for his poor grasp of Fiqh on this issue. Despite his deep reliance on the Arabic language, Al-Shinqīṭi rejects the view of Tāj Al-‘Arūs on an issue. Tāj Al-‘Arūs is one of the most authoritative sources on Arabic language. Al-Shinqīṭi recognises that just because several major Sahaba interpret a verse in one way, it does not follow that their interpretation is valid. If Ali and Ibn Abbas interpreted a verse in the same way, this does not mean, in and of itself, that the verse should be interpreted that way. Stronger evidence is needed to accept this interpretation.
The critical understanding Al-Shinqīṭi exhibits in dealing with the Quran is a result of his prioritisation of Quranic intertextuality. Since the Quran itself has priority over anyone else’s opinion, then Al-Shinqīṭi has the right to take a critical stance that is willing to reject views that many eminent scholars upheld. Quranic intertextuality brings with it a critical perspective that is laudatory in its incisive inquiry.
We have noted five features of Al-Shinqīṭi’s analysis of the Quran when dealing with the issue of contradictions. He deals with the Quran as a holistic whole, utilising the Surah-by-Surah method. He uses the technique of copious citations to move the discussion from individual verses to major themes in the Quran. He relies greatly on Arabic poetry in order to understand the eloquent linguistic usages in the Quranic text. He finds coherence in the Quran by applying Uṣūl Al-Fiqh to the Quran. Lastly, he prioritises Quranic intertextuality, even above the majority views of the scholars. Using all these five elements in his analysis, Al-Shinqīṭi can easily show that all contradictions in the Quran are actually not contradictions at all.
Before seeing Al-Shinqīṭi in action, it is important to quickly see his view regarding the exact nature of contradictions in Quran. The title of his book expresses his view succinctly. He uses the word Idhṭirāb ( ‘inconsistency’) but qualifies it with the word Īyhām ( ‘illusions’). The title has the phrase “illusory inconsistencies” which is what Al-Shinqīṭi calls the ‘contradictions’ in the Quran. Throughout his monograph, Al-Shinqīṭi repeatedly calls the contradictions he highlights as “illusions”. He apologises for mentioning such weak ‘contradictions,’ but says that some people who refuse to read the Quran try to purposefully distort the Quranic message. For Al-Shinqīṭi, the litany of contradictions in the Quran is merely a list of self-delusions on the part of detractors. But he feels duty bound to explain and expound on these contradictions and expose them for what they are: mere illusions. Keeping this in mind, it is clear that Al-Shinqīṭi does not see any problems in the Quran that need to be solved. All he sees is misconceptions that arise from people not properly understanding the Quran.
Part 2: Al-Shinqīṭi dealing with contradictions in the Quran
This part will provide a selection of ten contradictions that Al-Shinqīṭi dealt with. This selection is being provided so that readers can get a taste of Al-Shinqīṭi’s method in dealing with contradictions in the Quran.
Contradiction 1:
Q.2:2 says “This is a book in which there is no doubt, a guidance to the God-fearing.”
This verse states that the Quran is a guidance specifically to those with Taqwa. This seems to contradict another verse.
Q.2:185 says: “It was in the month of Ramadan that the Quran was revealed as guidance for mankind”.
This verse states that the Quran is a guidance even to those who do not have Taqwa.
Solution 1:
Al-Shinqīṭi says that a careful reading of the entire Quran shows there are two types of guidance. The first type of guidance is general; the second type of guidance is specific. General guidance is when the evidences and proofs of the truth have been conveyed, even if the people whom it was conveyed to rejected the guidance. This type of guidance is mentioned in Q.41:17, which says: “As for Thamud, We gave them guidance but they preferred blindness”.
Specific guidance is when Allah blesses a person with choosing the truth and following it. This type of guidance is mentioned in Q.6:125, which says: “When God wishes to guide someone, He opens their breast to Islam”.
The Quran is both a general and specific guidance. It is a general guidance, because it provides evidences and proofs of the truth of Tawhid to the entire mankind. It is a specific guidance, because those whom Allah blesses follow the Quran and benefit from its teachings. Based on this, there is no contradiction at all.
Contradiction 2:
Q.2:7 says: “God has sealed their hearts and their ears, and their eyes are covered.”
This verse shows that God stopped people from accepting the truth, by sealing their hearts, ears, and eyes from noticing the truth. This seems to contradict other verses.
Q.18:29 says: “Now the truth has come from your Lord: let those who wish to believe in it do so, and let those who wish to reject it do so.”
This verse shows that people freely choose disbelief and that God does not stop them in making their own free choice.
Solution 2:
Al-Shinqīṭi says that Q.2:7 is not talking about the disbelief of these people; rather, the verse is talking about God’s punishment on them. The sealing of their hearts, ears, and eyes are God’s punishment for their prior freely-chosen disbelief. Al-Shinqīṭi provides copious citations to prove his point. Amongst his citations are:
Q.4:155 says “And so for breaking their pledge, for rejecting God’s revelations, for unjustly killing their prophets, for saying ‘Our minds are closed’––No! God has sealed them in their disbelief, so they believe only a little”. In this verse, God seals their hearts as punishment for their breaking of the pledge, for their rejection of revelation, for their murdering of prophets, and for their mockery towards the religion.
Q.63:3 says “Because they professed faith and then rejected it, so their hearts have been sealed and they do not understand.” In this verse, God seals their hearts after they apostatised from the religion. The verse mentions the apostasy before the sealing of the hearts; so, the apostasy was not caused by the sealing of their hearts; rather, the exact opposite occurred. Their apostasy was the cause for their hearts to be sealed.
Q. 61:5 says: “Moses said to his people, ‘My people, why do you hurt me when you know that I am sent to you by God?’ When they went astray, God made their hearts go astray”. They persecuted Moses and went astray from his teachings. As punishment, God made them go even more astray. Their persecution of Moses and their going astray occurred before God made them go astray.
Q. 83:14 says: “No indeed! Their hearts are encrusted with what they have done.” The verse says their hearts are covered over as a result of their evil actions.
Moreover, Al-Shinqīṭi stresses that Q.2:7 is self-evidently referring to punishment for prior disbelief; since, Q.2:10 explicitly says so. Q.2:10 says: “There is a disease in their hearts, so God increased their disease”. Here the verse is explicit in mentioning two diseases in their hearts. The first disease is from them. The second disease is from God. Thus, God punished them with further misguidance after they freely-chose to be misguided prior. Based on this, Al-Shinqīṭi shows how Q,2:7 does not contradict the free-will of those who choose disbelief.
Contradiction 3:
Q.2:29 says “It was He who created all that is on the earth for you, then turned to the sky and made the seven heavens”.
This verse states that God created the earth fully first, then only later created the sky. This is further corroborated by Q.41:9-12, which says “Say, ‘How can you disregard the One who created the earth in two Days? How can you set up other gods as His equals? He is the Lord of all the worlds!’ He placed solid mountains on it, blessed it, measured out its varied provisions for all who seek them––all in four Days. Then He turned to the sky, which was smoke––He said to it and the earth, ‘Come into being, willingly or not,’ and they said, ‘We come willingly’––and in two Days He formed seven heavens, and assigned an order to each”. So here it is clear the earth was created fully before the sky.
This seems to contradict other verses.
Q.79:27-33 says: “Which is harder to create: you people or the sky that He built, raising it high and perfecting it, giving darkness to its night and bringing out its morning brightness, and the earth, too, He spread out, bringing waters and pastures out of it, and setting firm mountains [in it] for you and your animals to enjoy?” In this verse, it states God formed the earth after the sky was created.
Solution 3:
Al-Shinqīṭi provides a unique solution to this contradiction. He notes that many scholars have provided different explanations on this, but their explanations are extremely weak. He acknowledges that Ibn Abbas’s explanation is unsatisfactory. Al-Shinqīṭi finds the solution in Quranic intertextuality.
It is important to keep our focus on the essential details. Al-Shinqīṭi wants to show that the earth was created first, but not fully formed. Then the sky was created and fully formed. After that, God fully formed the earth. Q.2:29 & Q.41:9-13 seem to show that the earth was both created and fully formed before the sky was created and formed. Q.79:27-33 shows that the earth was fully formed after the sky was created and formed.
Al-Shinqīṭi forwards two linguistic points. The first deals with Arabic language. The second deals with Quranic usage.
In the Arabic language, the word Khalq (‘creation’) has two meanings. It can mean Khalq Taqdīr, which is when a person makes a plan prior to starting a project. For instance, when an architect makes the blueprint design for a skyscraper, he is regarded as the creator of the architecture, even though he did not lift his finger in building the actual skyscraper. The word can also mean Khalq Bi Al-Fi’l, which is when something is brought from non-existence into existence. To use the architecture analogy, the builders working in the building site are the ones who brought the skyscraper into its final form. Q.41:9-13 says that God created what is on earth before He created the sky. The verses refer to Khalq Taqdīr and not Khalq Bi Al-Fi’l. This is clear from the verse itself, because Q.41:11 says “measured out its varied provisions”. The Arabic word for “measured” here is Qaddara, which is the same as Taqdīr. Thus, from a close analysis of the Arabic language in Q.41:9-13, it is clear that the creation of the earth which is being described is actually God making the plan, by measuring out the various proportions of what He wants to do to the earth after He finished creating and forming the sky. That is, before creating the sky, Allah had set a plan and blueprint for the architecture of the earth. After God finished creating the sky, He then implemented that plan and blueprint on earth.
In Quranic usage, it is common for a verse to mention all the members within a category by referring to the origins of the category itself. Al-Shinqīṭi cites Q.7:11 as an example of this. Q.7:11 says “We created you, We gave you shape, and then We said to the angels, ‘Bow down before Adam,’ and they did. But not Iblis: he was not one of those who bowed”. The verse refers to all humans, and uses the plural form instead of the singular form, even though it only refers to Adam, who is a single person. Moreover, a plurality of humans did not exist at the time, even from the verse’s own text; yet, the Quran refers to a plurality of humans. Based on this Quranic usage, Q.2:29 becomes easier to comprehend.
Q.2:29 says “It was He who created all that is on the earth for you, then turned to the sky and made the seven heavens”. Following Quranic usage, Al-Shinqīṭi says this verse refers to the origins of the earth, and not the completed form of the earth. In the same way the Quran mentions the creation of all humans by referring to the origins of humans, Q2:29 mentions the creation of all that is on earth by referring to the origins of the earth.
With these two points, Al-Shinqīṭi can easily resolve the contradiction. God first created the origins of the earth (Q.2:29). After that God established a plan for the formation of the earth in accurate measurements (Q.49:9-13). God then created and formed the sky, after which God implemented His plan for forming the earth fully (Q.79:27-33). There is no contradiction here, as is clear.
What makes Al-Shinqīṭi’s argument persuasive is its lack of extravagance. Al-Shinqīṭi does not invoke any philosophical systems or physical theories by which he tries to resolve the apparent contradiction. Al-Shinqīṭi does not resort to ancient mythologies of world creation in his explanation. What Al-Shinqīṭi does is use the Arabic language and Quranic intertextuality to show a coherent way of understanding all the verses on this issue. Both the Arabic language and Quranic intertextuality are from within the Quranic text itself; since, the Quran is in Arabic and the Quranic usage is (obviously) not foreign to the Quranic text. Thus, Al-Shinqīṭi’s solution cannot be assailed by the charges of being ad hoc.
Contradiction 4:
Q.3:7 says “It is He who has sent this Book down to you [Prophet]. Some of its verses are definite in meaning––these are the cornerstone of the Book––and others are ambiguous.”
The keywords in this verse are Muhkam (‘definite’) and Mutashābih (‘ambiguous’). The verse says some Quranic verses are Muhkam and some Quranic verses are Mutashābih. This seems to contradict other verses. Q.11:1 says that all Quranic verses are Muhkam. Q.39:23 says that the entire Quran is Mutashābih.
Q.11:1 says “A Book whose verses are Mukham”.
Q.39:23 says “A Book that is Mutashābih”.
Solution 4:
Al-Shinqīṭi emphasises how in the Arabic language, the same word can have different meanings. The word Muhkam can mean ‘definite’. It can also mean ‘perfected’. Al-Shinqīṭi says Q.11:1 refers to the all the Quranic verses being perfect in their eloquence, i.e. linguistic perfection. This is what the word Muhkam means in the verse.
The word Mutashābih can mean ‘ambiguous’. It can also mean ‘similar’. Al-Shinqīṭi says Q.39:23 refers to how the Quranic verses are similar to each other in that all of them are the truth from Allah.
As for Q.3:7, Al-Shinqīṭi says the word Muhkam refers to self-evident verses such as Q.17:39 that says: “Do not set up another god beside God”. Anyone who reads this verse will understand its meaning, even if he is not a scholarly expert. As for Mutashābih, it can have one of two meanings, depending on where the reciter pauses in reading the verse.
The reciter can read Q.3:7 as “only God knows the true meaning and those firmly grounded in knowledge”. Here the reciter pauses after the phrase “firmly grounded in knowledge”. Based on this, Mutashābih means all the Quranic verses that only the Islamic scholars understand, but which the laymen are unqualified to understand. Examples of this include verses pertaining to complex Fiqh issues that the average Muslim lacks expertise in.
The reciter can read Q.3:7 as “only God knows the true meaning” (pause) “Those firmly grounded in knowledge..” (till end of verse). Here the reciter pauses before the mention of “those firmly grounded in knowledge”. Based on this, Mutashābih means specifically the letters that appear in the beginning of some Surahs. These are famously known as the Ḥurūf Al-Muqaṭṭa’a. In fact, Chapter 3 of the Quran opens with such a verse: “Alif Lām Mīm”. Only God knows what these letters mean.
Reading Q.3:7 the first way means that many verses in the Quran are Mutashābih, but that the meaning of these verses are known to Islamic scholars. Reading Q.3:7 the second way means that almost all the verses in the Quran are Muhkam.
Al-Shinqīṭi’s response shows the versatility of the Arabic language, with the same words having different meanings, depending on which verses they are found in, and also depending on where a person pauses in his recitation of the same verse.
Contradiction 5:
Q.4:78 says: “When good fortune comes their way, they say, ‘This is from God,’ but when harm befalls them, they say, ‘This is from you [Prophet].’ Say to them, ‘Both come from God.’ What is the matter with these people that they can barely understand what they are told.” This verse says that both good and bad comes from God. But this seems to contradict the very next verse.
Q.4:79 says: “Anything good that happens to you [Prophet] is from God; anything bad is from yourself.” Here good comes from God and bad comes from the person.
Solution 5:
Al-Shinqīṭi says the solution for this is easily found in the Quran. Q.4:78 refers to the pagans of Mecca. By “good fortune” they meant rain and vegetation; since, these were precious in the desert. Whenever it rained in Mecca, the Pagans would thank God for the rain. By “bad fortune” they meant droughts and dead crops. Whenever a prolonged drought occurred, and when their vegetation died from lack of water, the Pagans of Mecca would curse Muhammad and blame him for their bad fortune. The Pagans claimed that Muhammad had a curse upon him which was affecting the entire Mecca.
Using Quranic intertextuality, Al-Shinqīṭi shows how Muhammad’s confrontation with the pagans of Mecca mirrors exactly Moses’ confrontation with the pagans of Pharaonic Egypt. Q.7:130-1 says: “We inflicted years of drought and crop failure on Pharaoh’s people, so that they might take heed, then, when something good came their way, they said, ‘This is our due!’. When something bad came, they ascribed it to the evil omen of Moses and those with him, but their ‘evil omen’ was really from God, though most of them did not realize it.” When Egypt had rain and vegetation, Pharaoh saw this as a sign of him being on the truth. When drought and dead crops plagued Egypt, Pharaoh blamed Moses for it. Pharaoh claimed that Moses was an “evil omen” who cursed the land.
In both instances of Muhammad and Moses, the good fortune refers to rain and vegetation. Of course, these comes from God; since, God is the one who created both rain and vegetation. In both instances, the bad fortune was actually a punishment from God to the pagans of Mecca and Egypt. For that reason, both Muhammad and Moses respond to the pagans in the same way. They point out that the bad fortune is not a curse or evil omen on them; rather, the bad fortune is a punishment from God.
Q.4:79 expands on this point. Rain and vegetation are blessings from God that God sends to people out of His Mercy. The punishments from God are the result of the people’s own actions. These punishments come from God’s justice. And God’s justice is always tied to a person’s own actions. As Q.42:30 says “Whatever misfortune befalls you [people], it is because of what your own hands have done”. The misfortune is a punishment from God, as a result of the people’s own actions.
Thus, Q.4:78-9 do not contradict each other; rather, they complement each other nicely. Q.4:78 says that rain and drought, vegetation and dead crops, all of this comes from God. Q4:79 then explains that rain and vegetation is from God’s mercy, whereas drought and dead crops is a punishment from God due to the people’s evil actions. The coherence here is clear.
Contradiction 6:
Q.6:148 it says “The idolaters will say, ‘If God had willed, we would not have ascribed partners to Him––nor would our fathers––or have declared anything forbidden.’ In the same way, those before them continually denied [the truth] until they tasted Our punishment.” This verse, it is claimed, is self-contradictory. Muslims accept that the first part of the verse is true; yet, the Quran labels it false in the second part of the verse.
1st part: “If God had willed, we would not have ascribed partners to Him––nor would our fathers––or have declared anything forbidden.”
2nd part: “In the same way, those before them continually denied [the truth] until they tasted Our punishment”.
The same self-contradiction is found in another verse.
Q.43:20 says “They say, ‘If the Lord of Mercy had willed it, we would not have worshipped them,’ but they do not know that––they are only guessing”. Muslims accept the first part; yet, the second part of the verse rejects it.
1st part: “If the Lord of Mercy had willed it, we would not have worshipped them”.
2nd part: “but they do not know that––they are only guessing”.
Solution 6:
Al-Shinqīṭi refers to the famous Arabic aphorism: “A true statement that is used to mean falsehood.” Both Q.6:148 & Q.43:20 criticise the pagans for doing this. Al-Shinqīṭi explains that there is a clear difference between God allowing something, and God loving something. God allows the pagans to freely choose paganism. It does not follow from this that God loves paganism. In Q.6:148 & Q.43:20, the pagans conclude that God loves paganism; since, God allowed them to be pagan. But the Quran is clear that God hates paganism. Q.39:7 says “He is not pleased by disbelief in His servants.” That is why Q.6:148 & Q.43:20 criticise the pagans for using a true statement in order to justify their false beliefs. There is no contradiction here.
Contradiction 7:
Q.7:6 says “We shall certainly question those to whom messengers were sent–– and We shall question the messengers themselves.” This verse describes how in the Day of Judgment God will question people. This is further supported by Q.15:92-3 that says, “by your Lord, We will question them all about their deeds.”
This seems to contradict other verses in the Quran.
Q.55:39 says “On that Day neither mankind nor jinn will be asked about their sins.” This verse says there will be no questioning in the Day of Judgement.
Q.28:78 says “The guilty will not be questioned about their sins.”
Solution 7:
Al-Shinqīṭi refers to both the Arabic language and Quranic usage. In the Arabic language, there are different types of questions. Two major types of questions are: rhetorical and inquisitive. Rhetorical questions are usually asked in the form ‘why did you do..’ Inquisitive questions are usually asked in the form ‘did you do…’. Rhetorical questions are not aimed at finding new information; rather, their aim is to silence a person. Inquisitive questions aim at finding new information.
In Quranic usage, rhetorical questions are used to humiliate evil people into recognising their own evilness. This is the type of questions the Quran relates to the Day of Judgement. Al-Shinqīṭi gives many examples, amongst them:
Q.37:24-39 says “and halt them for questioning: “Why do you not support each other now?” ’––no indeed! They will be in complete submission on that Day––and they will turn on one another accusingly. They will say, ‘You came to us from a position of power.’ They will say, ‘No! It was you who would not believe.’” Here the question was to highlight how powerless they are on the Day of Judgement.
Q.52:14-16 says “‘This is the Fire you used to deny. So is this sorcery? Do you still not see it? Burn in it––it makes no difference whether you bear it patiently or not–– you are only being repaid for what you have done.’” The question mocks those who used to claim the Prophets used sorcery, by asking them if Hell is sorcery once they witness it for themselves.
Q.6:130 says “‘Company of jinn and mankind! Did messengers not come from among you to recite My revelations to you and warn that you would meet this Day?’ They will say, ‘We testify against ourselves.’ The life of this world seduced them, but they will testify against themselves that they rejected the truth.” Here the question is to force them to testify against themselves.
Following the Arabic language and Quranic usage, Al-Shinqīṭi makes this adroit point. The Quran affirms that rhetorical questions will be asked in the Day of Judgement. But the Quran denies that inquisitive questions will be asked in the Day of Judgment. This difference also is in line with Islam’s theological teachings. Allah does not need inquisitive questions, because He is All-Knowing. He doesn’t need to find any new information. The questions that are asked in the Day of Judgement are only rhetorical, in that it forces people to acknowledge their evil. Based on this, Q.7:6 & Q.15:92-3 refers to rhetorical questions. Q.55:39 & Q.28:78 refers to inquisitive questions. There is no contradiction between affirming one type of questions and negating another type of questions.
Contradiction 8:
Q.13:7 says “But you are only there to give warning: each community had their guide”.
This verse states that every community had a Prophet sent to them. This seems to contradict other verses.
Q. 36:6 says “To warn a people whose forefathers were not warned, and so they are unaware.”
This verse states that some communities never had any Prophet sent to them.
Solution 8:
Al-Shinqīṭi points to Quranic usage. In the Quran, the word ‘guide’ and ‘guidance’ does not only refer to Prophets and the truth, but also to the devils and falsehood. Al-Shinqīṭi provides copious citations to prove this point. From amongst the citations are:
Q.22:4 says “fated to lead astray those who take his side, and guide them to the suffering of the blazing flame”. So the guidance here leads to Hell.
Q.37:23 says “beside God, guide them all to the path of Hell.”
The Quran also describes evil and ignorant people as “Imams,” a word more commonly associated with piety and knowledge.
Q.28:40 says “We made them Imams calling [others] only to the Fire”.
Following Quranic usage, Al-Shinqīṭi says Q.13:7 refers to how every community has a guide, either to goodness or to evil. The guide to goodness is from the Prophets. The guide to evil is from the devil. Thus, even communities who never got Prophets still had a guide, as is evident from the many evil communities across human history. Al-Shinqīṭi’s solution is an ingenious use of Quranic intertextuality.
Contradiction 9:
Q.17:97 says “On the Day of Resurrection We shall gather them, lying on their faces, blind, dumb, and deaf”.
This verse says that evil people will be blind and deaf in the Day of Judgement. But this seems to contradict other verses.
Q.18:53 says “The evildoers will see the Fire and they will realize that they are about to fall into it: they will find no escape from it.” So they do see.
Q.32:12 says “if only you could see the wrongdoers hang their heads before their Lord: ‘Our Lord, now that we have seen and heard, send us back and we shall do good. [Now] we are convinced.’” So they do speak, see, and hear.
Solution 9:
Al-Shinqīṭi refers to Arabic language. In the Arabic language, if something does not bring any benefit to a person, the person can be described as if he lacks that something. In reference to Q.17:97, the evil people are described as blind, because they will not see anything that benefits them; they are described as dumb, because they will not say anything that benefits them; they are described as deaf because they will not hear anything that benefits them. Thus, Q.17:97 does not deny that the evil people will see Hell, or speak pleadingly to God, or hear the judgement passed against them.
Contradiction 10:
Q.55:35 says “A flash of fire and smoke will be released upon you and no one will come to your aid.” This verse refers to a punishment from God. The very next verse Q.55:36 says “Which, then, of your Lord’s blessings do you both deny?”
The verse describes the punishment of God as blessings. Both verses seem to contradict each other, because one verse talks of God’s punishment and the other describes it as God’s blessings.
Solution 10:
Al-Shinqīṭi points out that it is a blessing for the Quran to warn people against God’s punishment; so, they can take heed and avoid it by acting righteously.
Al-Shinqīṭi deals with far more contradictions than the selection above presents. It is hoped, however, that the selection will have given the readers a snap shot of Al-Shinqīṭi’s approach in resolving any so-called contradictions in the Quran. For readers interested in learning more about this, they are recommended to reader Al-Shinqīṭi’s monograph in its entirety.
Part 3: Using Al-Shinqīṭi’s Method to Deal with Contemporary Detractors
Al-Shinqīṭi’s method in dealing with Quranic contradictions focuses most on Arabic language and Quranic intertextuality. Al-Shinqīṭi shows how versatile the Arabic language is, where the same word can have multiple different meanings. He also shows how Quranic usage is a fundamental tool in correctly understanding Quranic verses. The prioritisation of Quranic intertextuality allows Al-Shinqīṭi’s position to exhibit an organic interpretation that is grounded in the Quran itself, and is not an foreign imposition onto the Quranic text.
This method brings to light a crucial weakness in the anti-Islamic polemics regarding so-called contradictions in the Quran. The Quranic text is stable and uniform. There is a consensus amongst all Muslims that the Mushaf is indeed the Quran. The Arabic language has been studied for centuries, and has taken an established form that is the basis for Arabic literary and linguistic scholarship. These two factors have very little to no change at all in the conceivable future. 100 years into the future, the Quran will still be the Quran. Muslims will still recite Surah Al-Fatiha in their prayers. And while modern Arabic studies is evolving, the classical Arabic heritage is already established and won’t change. The detractors now face two daunting challenges.
When detractors claim the Quran is contradictory, they have to explain two crucial points. Firstly, since the Quran and Arabic literary-linguistic scholarship were stable for many centuries, why is it that Arabic experts in the past never found out about these contradictions? Secondly, since the Quran and classical Arabic heritage won’t change in the foreseeable future, what new feature in the Quran or in classical Arabic heritage did the detractors find that no one else knew about before?
Both crucial points revolve around the same issue, which is the crucial weakness of all claims of contradictions in the Quran. The issue of contradictions is solely a matter of Arabic language and Quranic intertextuality. Arabic language is stable, while the Quranic usage is constant. These two areas have been settled with centuries ago. When detractors say two verses contradict each other, they have to refer to Arabic language and Quranic usage. If they fail to do so, their claims of contradictions fall flat before even beginning.
To better understand the point, a comparison can be made with the so-called scientific contradictions in the Quran. From the onset, the notion of new scientific facts contradicting the Quran is plausible. This is because, in principle, no one can say what science will discover in the future. The future of scientific discovery is left wide-open and cannot be specified at all. Thus, it makes sense that a future scientific discovery may contradict the Quran. In contrast, the claim that there is a linguistic contradiction in the Quran is, at the onset, implausible. There is no such thing as ‘future of classical Arabic linguistic discovery’ or ‘future of Quranic intertextual discovery’. Both the categories are already established and solidified. In more laymen terms, scientific contradictions in the Quran is always forward looking into the future (of possible scientific discoveries that may contradict the Quran). But linguistic contradictions in the Quran is always backward looking into the past (to see Arabic language usage in poetry and Quranic usage in the Mushaf). Thus, the claim of Quranic contradictions is perhaps the weakest position detractors can take. In order to prove their point, they must engage with centuries of established linguistic norms and Quranic interpretative schemes.
For that reason, whenever Muslims face a detractor claiming to have found a contradiction in the Quran, a simple set of considerations will expose how whimsical the detractor’s claim is. If the contradiction occurs because one word or one idea is affirmed in a verse then negated in another verse, the detractor has to show how this word or idea does not have multiple meanings in the Arabic language and Quranic usage. If the Arabic language is clear on a point, and the Quranic verse contradicts this, then the detractor must explain firstly the various Quranic usages that are similar to the Quranic verse. It is well-known that the Quran has its own unique stylistic features; so, it could be that the Quranic verse is exhibiting those unique features, which is divergent from the standard features of the Arabic language. If the detractor provides an English translation of two verses, then a Muslim has the full right to not take the detractor seriously. English translations of the Quran have the unfortunate disadvantage of limiting the linguistic scope of the original Arabic verses. Translators select the meaning they want for the words in the verses; however, whatever selection they make will not exhaust the multifaceted versatility of the Quranic text. When a detractor provides two contradictory verses, he should be asked to provide copious citations for other similar verses in the Quran. More often than not, the detractor won’t be able to do this.
I will end this section by one example taken from widespread anti-Islamic online polemics. WikiIslam has a page on “Contradictions in the Quran”. I randomly picked the following example by scrolling down the page with my eyes closed.
“When do people come back to life?
On the appointed Hour (Day of Judgement):
“And verily the Hour will come: there can be no doubt about it, or about (the fact) that Allah will raise up all who are in the graves” (22:7).
Immediately after their death:
“Think not of those, who are slain in the way of Allah, as dead. Nay, they are living. With their Lord they have provision” (3:169).”
It is obvious that whoever wrote this can neither read Arabic nor has even the most basic familiarity with Islamic theology (Aqidah). Q.22:7 uses the word Yab’athu ( ‘raised up’) which refers to the Ba’th (‘resurrection’). This verse refers to people being resurrected in the Day of Judgement. The verse itself is explicit in mentioning people coming out of their graves. Q.3:169 has no relation to the resurrection. Indeed, the apparent meaning of the verse refers to the martyrs who are in their graves. Thus, WikiIslam is taking two unrelated verses and pretending they contradict each other. The first verse refers to people leaving their graves during the resurrection. The second verses refers to martyrs in their graves before the resurrection.
Anyone who is familiar with basic Islamic theology will recognise that Q3:169 refers to the life of the Barzakh (of the grave). The verse states that when martyrs die, they will be rewarded with a special type of life while they are in their graves. This life is not a physical life at all, but a spiritual life; since, the resumption of a physical life only occurs after the resurrection in Islamic eschatology. So Q.3:169 refers to the life of the Barzakh, whereas Q.22:7 refers to life of the Akhira. Here, WikiIslam clearly was thinking in a non-Muslim manner by equating life = life, whereas Islamic theology makes it clear that life of Barzakh ≠ life of Akhira.
Such a contention only shows how the detractors are ignorant of Islam. This ignorance is so apparent, it makes one realise how these detractors are not serious at all about understanding Islam. If we compare how Al-Shinqīṭi deals with the Quran and how such detractors deal with it, we will notice immediately how shallow the detractors are in their engagement with the Quranic text. By studying how Islamic scholars dealt with so-called contradictions, Muslims will be able to critique the anti-Islamic narrative on this issue, both from a methodological and textual perspective. This is why learning about Al-Shinqīṭi’s approach to this issue is valuable.