• March 31, 2021
  • No Comment
  • 1634

DOES THE QURAN SAY THE EARTH SITS ON THE BACK OF A WHALE?

There is not a single verse in the Quran that says the earth sits on the back of a whale.…

 DOES THE QURAN SAY THE EARTH SITS ON THE BACK OF A WHALE?

There is not a single verse in the Quran that says the earth sits on the back of a whale. This can easily be proven. In his lexicon of the Quran, Rāghib Al-Isfahāni has an entry for Ḥūt (‘whale’ or ‘fish’). Only three Quranic verses are referenced in the entry. They are: 18:61, 37:142, 7:163. None of them are remotely related to the earth sitting on a whale’s back.

There is a (non-Quranic) narration that states the earth sits on the back of a whale. But Shawkani cites Imam Dhahabi as stating that the narration is Munkar (‘rejected’). In reference to the verse {Nūn}, Shawkani mentions that some scholars interpreted this to mean a whale upon whose back the earth rests. But Shawkani immediately rejects this interpretation. The verse, he says, is no different from the other opening verses in the Quran that consist of single letters unconnected to words.
Al-Alūsi is emphatic that the narration cannot be accepted “in principle” and that there are many similar rejected reports that have no value at all in understanding the Quran. In discussing the various interpretations of the narration, Al-Alūsi mentions Al-Ghazali who held an interesting position. According to Al-Ghazali, the Prophet was asked, “What is below the earth?” The Prophet replied: “The fish.” Another time, the Prophet replied: “The bull.” Al-Alūsi tells us that the answers refer to the constellations. The fish refers to Pisces (Burj Al-Ḥūt), while the bull refers to Taurus (Burj Al-Thawr). If at the time of being asked, the constellation most clear was Scorpio (Burj Al-‘Aqrab), then the Prophet would have answered the question with: “The scorpion is under the earth”. Even if the narration is accepted, scholars like Al-Ghazali understood the narration to refer to Pisces and not a physical whale.
Al-Alūsi’s favoured position is as follows: he emphasises that the Prophet’s aim was not to provide a detailed description of the natural world. The Quran’s focus on nature is strictly in prompting people to think over nature as a means of indicating the existence and oneness of God. Anything more than this is not within the purview of the Quran. This, Al-Alūsi says, is how the proper Iman should be regarding the Quran’s relation to the natural world.

Mustafa b. Al-‘Adawi states that there is not a single authentic narration linked to the Prophet saying that the earth sits on the back of a whale. Nāsir Al-Din Al-Albani is adamant that the whale narration is Mawdhū’ (‘fabricated’). Dr. Abu Shahiba was Professor of Quran & Sunnah studies at Al-Azhar University, Egypt, and Umm Al-Qurā University, Mecca. According to him, the whale narration is clearly fake and most probably from the Judeo-Christian tradition (Isrāīlīyāt) that was later mixed up with the Islamic tradition. Dr. Abu Shahiba cites Ibn Qayim who says such narrations were fabricated in order to make a mockery of the Prophets and portray their Prophetic message as nonsense. Dr Abu Shahiba also cites Abu Hayyan who says all such narrations are inauthentic.
What is clear is that the whale narration is not found in the Quran and is rejected by Islamic scholars as a fabrication. This is so clear it doesn’t even need a scholarly rebuttal. After all, Muslims read and listen to the Quran fully at least once a year during Ramadan. Not a single Muslim who prayed Tarawīh can ever recall hearing a Quranic verse mentioning the earth sitting on the back of a whale. Many Muslims read the entire Quran once every month. Not a single one of them ever read a verse saying that the earth is on top of a whale. One of the most popular Quranic reciters is Mishary b. Rashid Alafasy. Many Muslims across the world have listened to his beautiful recitation of the Quran. Not a single one of them heard Alafasy reading a Quranic verse saying the earth is on the back of a whale. That is why, at least to Muslims, the sceptics are levelling a preposterous charge against the Quran, which indicates the total lack of familiarity the sceptics have with the Quran.

 
It is noteworthy to take a closer look at how the sceptics have formulated this accusation against the Quran. Once looked at closely, this accusation unearths their main error that motivates their sceptical claims.

Sceptics point to the fact that Al-Tabari, in his famous Tafsir, included the whale narration. Sceptics note that Al-Tabari used the whale narration to interpret the Quran. This shows, so they say, that the Quranic verses mean the earth is on the back of a whale, as Al-Tabari himself states.
This type of argumentation is the epitome of quote-mining. In this argument, sceptics have persistently ignored many other relevant details.

Tafsir Al-Tabari is edited by Ahmad Muhammad Shakir, the famous hadith scholar, and his brother Mahmud Muhammad Shakir, the famous Arabic literature scholar. In a footnote, Ahmad Muhammad Shakir has this to say. Al-Tabari relies on a sanad (‘chain of narration’) that Al-Tabari himself explicitly acknowledges that he doesn’t think is authentic. Ahmad Muhammad Shakir stresses that Al-Tabari never used this sanad as evidence or proof of the correctness of any position. This sanad is not a Hujja ( ‘evidence’) for Al-Tabari. After Al-Tabari mentions the whale narration, Mahmud Muhammad Shakir makes an insightful observation. He highlights that the sanad for the whale narration is the same one that Al-Tabari admitted he doesn’t think is authentic. Mahmud Muhammad Shakir explains to us why Al-Tabari used narrations he knew were inauthentic. The scholarly tradition at Al-Tabari’s time was that readers of his Tafsir were qualified enough in hadith sciences to sift through the authentic and inauthentic by themselves. Al-Tabari never used these inauthentic narrations as evidence or proof; rather, he included them as mere illustrations and examples. Mahmud Muhammad Shakir tells us that the whale narration has its origins from the Sahaba (Companions) hearing about it from Jewish Rabbis. Neither the Quran nor the Prophetic hadiths contain this narration; hence, the whale narration is not part of Islam at all. It is merely a Judaic myth that was mentioned by some scholars in passing.
Furthermore, it is well-known amongst Islamic scholars that Tafsir Al-Tabari is filled with spurious narrations from the Judeo-Christian tradition (Isrāīlīyāt). Dr. Muhammad Hussein Al-Dhahabi was Professor of Quran & Sunnah studies at Al-Azhar University, Egypt. He wrote an entire book showing how the inclusion of the Judeo-Christian tradition into the Tafsir literature led to a distortion of the Quran’s meanings. Among his examples of this distortion is Tafsir Al-Tabari. According to Dr. Al-Dhahabi, Ibn Jarir Al-Tabari regularly cited narrations directly from Christians and Jews. Al-Tabari tried to gather as many strange and fantastic tales as possible in his Tafsir and didn’t criticise them for their lack of authenticity. One of the major flaws in his Tafsir is that Al-Tabari included lots of narrations that contradict Islam and that go against rationality. There are narrations in his Tafsir that are obviously fabrications and clearly fake. There are narrations that Al-Tabari records which are insults to the Prophets and are totally baseless. What is even worse, Al-Tabari included in his Tafsir some of the polemical fabrications that John of Damascus made up in order to mock Islam and slander the Prophet Muhammad. This flaw is compounded by Al-Tabari rarely criticising the fabricated narrations he includes so it seems, to the untrained eye, as if he accepts them. Dr. Dhahabi says that overall Tafsir Al-Tabari is valuable scholarship for understanding the Quran, but it is flawed by its uncritical inclusion of all sorts of fabricated narrations.

 
Knowing all of this, it becomes clear what the sceptics did in making their preposterous allegation against the Quran. The sceptics took one fabricated narration from a Tafsir that is well-known to contain fabricated narrations and then judged the entirety of the Quran based on this one fabrication. If anything, this shows the lack of seriousness the sceptics have in actually engaging with the Islamic scholarly tradition.

This shallow approach is used ad nauseam by sceptics. They will point out that Al-Qurtubi in his Tafsir mentions the whale narration. They don’t mention that Dr. Ramzi Na’nā’a, who obtained a doctorate specialising in Tafsir from Al-Azhar University, has pointed out that the whale narration is a superstition and mockery of Islam. This narration is a disgrace and makes Islam into a laughing-stock. Dr. Ramzi Na’nā’a criticises Al-Qurtubi for including this fabrication in his Tafsir.

Sceptics may refer to Ibn Mandah who includes the whale narration in his Kitab Al-Tawhid. But both Dr. Muhammad b. Abdullah Al-Wahaybi and Dr. Musa b. Abdel-Aziz Al-Ghusn clarified in their footnote that Ibn Mandah’s narration is rejected and inauthentic.
There is an important point here that must be emphasised. The Islamic tradition is 1,500 years old. It is self-evident that across 1,500 years, some ideas were espoused and some claims where endorsed that do not stand the test of credibility and credulity. It is ludicrous for sceptics to expect the Islamic tradition with a 1,500 year history to be so whitewashed and polished that not a single controversial idea or statement is found. That is not how any history works nor any rich tradition is formed. Instead the reality is less sensational and more prosaic. The Islamic tradition of 1,500 years is a mixture of different elements, different trends, different qualities. The scholars of Islam were well aware of this, which is why they emphasised that Muslims should have a critical approach to the Tafsir literature, instead of accepting everything they read there. The sceptics, on the other hand, hold a naivety that is hard to justify. Their main method of dealing with Islam is quote-mining. They will find one quote that sounds ridiculous and then claim that the entire Quran stands or falls with this ridiculous-sounding quote. Actually, any quote the sceptics pinpoint must first be placed in the wider context of the Islamic discourse. Once this is done, it becomes apparent that the ridiculous-sounding quote is both irrelevant and insignificant for dealing with the Quran and its message to humanity. The main error of sceptics is their quote-mining technique that betrays their lack of seriousness and absence of familiarity with the complexities of the Islamic tradition.
The Quran doesn’t say anywhere that the earth lies on the back of a whale. As Al-Alūsi had pointed out, the Quran’s aim is not to provide in-depth descriptions of the physical world; rather, the Quran’s aim is to awaken in people the appreciation of nature that makes them appreciate God, the Creator of Nature. The entire sceptical challenge misses its mark, because it takes a Judaic myth that was heard by some Muslims centuries ago, and tries to make this myth the basis of the Quran’s relation to Nature.