• March 31, 2021
  • No Comment
  • 1416

In Quran 16:15, there are two scientific errors. Firstly, the verse says that Allah {placed} mountains in the earth. The Arabic word used is Alqā, which means ‘to throw’. Science proves that mountains are part of the earth and not thrown into it from above. Secondly, the verse says mountains stabilise the earth, but in fact earthquakes still occur in areas with mountains. This all shows the verse contradicts science.

This contention exhibits a marked characteristic of many detractors. The contention tries to portray Islam and Muslims as if they…

 In Quran 16:15, there are two scientific errors. Firstly, the verse says that Allah {placed} mountains in the earth. The Arabic word used is Alqā, which means ‘to throw’. Science proves that mountains are part of the earth and not thrown into it from above. Secondly, the verse says mountains stabilise the earth, but in fact earthquakes still occur in areas with mountains. This all shows the verse contradicts science.

This contention exhibits a marked characteristic of many detractors. The contention tries to portray Islam and Muslims as if they are barbaric, backwards, to the point that they espouse the belief that mountains dropped down from the sky and crash-landed on earth. Anyone familiar with Islamic civilization will be aware of the absurdity of this contention.

A brief snapshot: Muzaffar Iqbal shows how the Quranic references to mountains spurred Muslim scholars and scientists to investigate geography, especially of the earth and its topography. Based on this, Al-Biruni articulated the geological theory that mountains were shaped by erosion across long centuries. According to David Deming, Ibn Sina explained mountain formation as due to three processes: earthquakes, land erosion, water erosion. Moreover, Deming notes that Ibn Sina anticipated, by centuries, Charles Lyell’s notion of “rigid uniformitariansism” which later established the field of modern geology. Not only did Muslim scholars and scientists discuss mountain formation on land, they also discussed mountain formation under the sea. Dr. Muhammad Muhamidayn highlights Al-Qazwīni’s discussion on mountains. Al-Qazwīni described how erosion of mountains on land led to rivers moving vast amounts of soil and stones to the sea. As time passes, the soil and stones accumulate inside the sea, until even mountains can develop underwater. As this brief snapshot shows, it is preposterous for anyone to claim that Islam or Muslims claim that Mt. Everest dropped from the sky and crash-landed on earth.


Regarding the world Alqā, we can consult the Arabic-English Dictionary of Quranic Usage by ElSaid M. Badawi & Muhammad Abdel Haleem. In the entry for the word, Badawi & Haleem provide 11 different definitions for the word, based on Quranic usage. The word Alqa in the Quran means: to throw down, to lay down, to bestow upon, to offer, to place on, to hurl into, to instigate, to bring forth, to entrust with, to communicate, to retort. Anyone familiar with the Arabic language recognises that one word can have multiple different meanings; so, the contention is untenable because it totally ignores the other meanings for the word Alqā in the Quran.

In fact, it is 100% guaranteed that the detractors who made this claim haven’t even read the verse they cite. This is the verse:

“He has placed (Alqā) mountains on the earth, to prevent it shaking under you, and rivers and paths so that you may find your way” (Q. 16:15).

The verse clearly states that Allah placed (Alqā) three things on the earth: mountains, rivers, and paths. If the contention is correct, and Alqā means ‘to throw,’ then detractors must claim the verse also says all the rivers in the world crash-landed on earth, and all the roads in the globe fell from the sky. But of course no Muslim ever claimed that motorways descended from heaven, or that the Nile collapsed from outer space into Egypt. Since no sane person, let alone a Muslim, would believe this, then clearly the detractors have a comical understanding of the verse. This is assuming, of course, that the detractors even read the full verse they are citing in the first place.


The second part of the contention clearly shows the detractors have zero relation to the Quran they are criticising. The verse obviously does not claim that earthquakes don’t happen. This is because the Quran itself mentions earthquakes decimating societies in the past (e.g. Q. 29:37). So if the Quran mentions earthquakes happening on earth, how can detractors claim the Quran denies earthquakes occur?!

As for mountains reducing the harm of earthquakes, this is well-known and established in science. For instance, in a study published in 2020, Sun, Saffer, & Ellis conducted computer simulations and discovered that undersea mountains weaken earthquakes. Their study was published in the prestigious journal Nature Geoscience. If a detractor wants to be funny, he may claim that the example cited refers to mountains in the sea, not in the land. Leaving aside the childish notion that there is no land in the sea, as if a sea bed doesn’t exist, other studies can be provided. Ma, Archuleta, & Page conducted a study on the San Gabriel Mountains and its relation to Los Angeles. They found that when an earthquake occurs, the San Gabriel Mountains reduces its intensity by up to 50%. They conclude that the San Gabriel Mountains act as a shield for Los Angeles, reducing seismic excitations from earthquakes. It is an embarrassing form of desperation if detractors go so far as to claim that science rejects the notion of mountains weakening earthquakes, just so they can ignore the Quranic parallel to modern science.

 
Whatever the case, Quran 16:15 is free from the two-pronged contention mentioned prior. The Quranic verse doesn’t say mountains fell from the sky, in the same way the Quranic verse doesn’t say motorways fell from the sky. The Quran never claimed that earthquakes are impossible; since, the Quran itself mentions earthquakes striking previous societies. All the Quranic verse states is that mountains play a role in making the earth shake less, which is what the latest scientific studies done in the field have proven.