• June 14, 2020
  • No Comment
  • 1194

The Prophet said black seed cures all diseases. This is medically false. Black seed cannot cure lung damage or HIV. Thus the Prophet spoke falsely.

The hadith in question is as follows. The Prophet said: “This black seed is healing for all diseases but poison.”…

 The Prophet said black seed cures all diseases. This is medically false. Black seed cannot cure lung damage or HIV. Thus the Prophet spoke falsely.

The hadith in question is as follows. The Prophet said: “This black seed is healing for all diseases but poison.” Aisha asked, “What is poison?” The Prophet said, “Death.”
The entire contention revolves around the word “all” (Arabic: Kul). It is well-known in the Arabic language that the word Kul refers to “many” or “a lot”. This is self-evident even from the Quran. In Q.7:149 it states:
“We inscribed everything for him in the Tablets which taught and explained everything, saying, ‘Hold on to them firmly and urge your people to hold fast to their excellent teachings. I will show you the end of those who rebel.”

The verse says that God wrote “everything” (Kul) in Moses’s Tablets and that these Tablets explained “everything” (Kul). No Muslim has ever claimed that Moses’s Tablets included descriptions of Biryani Rice or explanations on how to make Samosas. The verse self-evidently means that God wrote many things on Moses’s Tablets and that He explained many things on the Tablets.
This Arabic usage for the word Kul is similar even to the English language. People usually say: “All my life I was depressed.” They actually mean: ‘a lot of my life’ since even the most twisted misanthrope would still have experienced at least one or two moments of not being depressed. Similar statements in the English language include: “all my money is lost” (meaning: a lot, because they still have at least £1 left), “all my rights have been taken away” (meaning: a lot, because they still have the right to breath), “all my energy is used up” (meaning: a lot, because they still have energy to talk).
When the Prophet said black seed cures all (Kul) diseases, he clearly meant many diseases. The Arab Bedouins and nomads had found out, via centuries of experience, that black seed was very versatile as a medicine. They would carry with them black seed as they crossed the harsh desert in their camel caravans.

Moreover, no Islamic scholar has ever claimed that black seed is the cure to, literally, all, i.e. every single, disease. This can be easily proven. Al-Suyuti wrote a book entitled Medicine of the Prophet. He mentioned Habbat’l-Sauda (here rendered as ‘black seed’) in a section that is 1.5 pages long. The rest of the 200+ page book deals with other medical remedies. For instance, Al-Suyuti talks of the medical benefits of coffee beans and melons. Ginger helps digestion. Coconuts are a natural libido booster. If Al-Suyuti believed that black seed cured every single disease, he wouldn’t have written an entire book on medical remedies. He would have sufficed by writing his 1.5 pages on black seed and conclude that all sicknesses will be cured by using black seed. Of course he didn’t do that, and it would be absurd to imagine he ever thought like this.
Every single medical book written by Islamic scholars is a refutation of the nonsensical suggestion that in Islam only black seed is needed to cure all diseases! Scientifically, it is proven beyond doubt that consuming black seed does have some positive health benefits. That is all the hadith claims. Neither the Arabic language of the hadith nor the understanding of the Islamic scholars ever claimed that black seed can cure lung damage or HIV.